IAC logo
The Film & Video Institute

The SAM Members Competition 2005
By Dave Watterson
The Scottish Association of Moviemakers logo. Scottish Association of Moviemakers
Members Competition

BUDDHISM?  IT'S ELEMENTAL ...

It 's amazing how much you learn watching amateur movies. This year's Scottish Association of Moviemakers annual members'competition had a wealth of movies: 21 entries and almost 4 hours of video, packed with interest, amusement and delight. In the end two vied for top place with scarcely a whisker between them. The runner-up explained a great deal about Buddhism and especially how monks behave, concentrating on their role in Thai society. The winner took an old theme of illustrating the four elements and did it with style and great inventiveness.

Still from 'The Four Elements'.

Still from 'The Saffron Robe'.

Still from 'St Georges Day in Luton'.

The W.S. Smith Cup, top award, went to Pat Menmuir for The Four Elements. Based on the abstract themes of water, earth, air and fire this showed stunning images of Provence blended with appropriate music.

The Lizar's Salver for the runner-up went to Ken & Jean McRonald for The Saffron Robe. A charming, amusing Buddhist professor talks about the role of monks in everyday Thai life while we see their practice illustrated by a wide-range of pictures.

The Loudon Salver for the best novice entry went to William G. Hamper for St. George's Day, Luton. A kaleidoscope of scenes taken in Luton during celebrations in the sun - packed with great pictures of eccentric English folk.

Highly Commended awards went to Daphne Barbieri for A Cut Above the Rest, Dorothy Borrie for A Woman Scorned and Angus Allan for Pinstripe.  The winners were excellent and there was a wonderful choice on hand. The audience at the Albert Halls, Stirling, saw a great variety of material.  SAM adds the entries to their tape library so that clubs can hire the whole programme including the movies which time did not allow us to screen that afternoon. To give you a taste of the range of work:

Still from 'The Bridge'.

Still from 'Austria Old and New'.

Still from 'Gentle Giants'.

Still from 'Glamis Extravagansa'.

The Bridge by Drew Fleming & Frank Ramsey stars the Forth Road Bridge talking to us on its 40th birthday about how it is cared for.

Austria Old & New by Joe G. Gardiner features narrow gauge railways which helped open up the hidden valleys of Austria in the 19th century.

Gentle Giants by Daphne Barbieri features Sam and Fergus, two Clydesdale show horses during their working season.

Glamis Extravagansa by William Hamper is a pot-pourri of vintage cars, bikes, traction engines, machines, jets and people at a transport festival.

Still from 'Pinstripe'.

Still from 'A Stitch in Time'.

Still from 'A Woman Scorned'.

Still from 'Golf Course'.

Pinstripe is a quirky comedy by Angus Allan where a man waiting at a station discovers a lesser-known hazard of rail transport.

A Stitch in Time by Ken & Jean McRonald shows one way for a wife to punish her errant husband. Tragedy turns to the comedy of revenge.

A Woman Scorned shows the dangers of taking an assistant for granted. Dorothy Borrie directed the Perth Club in this very funny movie.

Golf is a heavenly game it seems but that's just the good news ... Bert McCready reveals more. Groan-worthy humour.

Still from 'Crackers'.

Still from 'Mayhem'.

Still from 'Arbroath Instrumental Band'.

Still from 'A Cut Above The Rest'.

Dorothy Borrie directs the Perth team in the tale of two crooks fresh out of jail who are determined not to go straight. No wonder she calls them Crackers.

Still in his seaside postcard style of broad comedy Bert McCready paints a tale of terrible Mayhem resulting from a simple golfing slice.

Alec Mollison intercuts shots of Arbroath Instrumental Band playing with images of the town which match the mood of the music perfectly.

Pirie & Son offer a butcher service that is A Cut Above The Rest according to Daphne Barbieri who won their trust and recorded the creation of their award-winning dishes.

Still from 'The Keys of Edinburgh Castle'.

Still from 'A Brief Look at Skipton'.

Still from 'Gone To Pot'.

Still from 'Bannockburn 2004'.

The last ceremonial appearance of The Royal Scots at the ceremony of presenting The Keys of Edinburgh Castle to its new governor. Drew Fleming & Frank Ramsey filmed it.

That busy man Brian Saberton only had time for A Brief Look at Skipton but showed us the historic charms of this lovely Yorkshire market town.

Tim Heilbronn makes the haggis-whistle - of a type possibly used by Robert Burns to summon  wild haggis. Pat Lawrence shows how they are made in Gone to Pot.

Bannockburn 2004 is a tribute to the brave soggy souls who demonstrated ancient weapons, played music and recreated the battle on a very wet weekend. Edinburgh Cine & Video Society members saw it all.

Still from 'The Old West Kirk of Greenock'.

Still from 'Our Italian Adventure'.

I judged the competition in advance then presented the programme of top movies at Stirling's Albert Halls on Sunday 3rd April 2005.

"Somehow I managed to give part of my talk from inside a bubble-wrap bag (!) and to change ties between films in tribute to some gaudy neckware which went through the shredder in one movie."

Portrait of Dave Watterson.

Dave Watterson, FACI

The Old West Kirk of Greenock is a quirky building with a fascinating history revealed by Margaret Mackay. Bert McCready recorded her tour.

When Vince Picozzi  and his wife started to search for their Italian ancestry they found the wonderful beauty of northern Italy overwhelming in Our Italian Adventure.


Page updated on 02 March 2008

Authors' views are not necessarily those of The Institute of Amateur Cinematographers

Free JavaScripts provided
by The JavaScript Source