IAC logo
The Film & Video Institute

NLE for Analogue VHS
The Nellie Corner

computer enthusiast at work NLE for analogue VHS ... and for 32 pounds?
Tim Hanitszch found a way.

Huh?

Being webmaster is sometimes pretty amazing.
It was double-take time.  I had an email about computer editing of VHS material!  Then the author mentioned the cost and it was triple-take time.  But let Tim explain:

I really wanted to go down the DV route but cost was prohibitive, so after much research and chatting to people on line I plunged straight into desk top editing by digitising analogue VHS. I achieved a modest set-up which allows me to capture full-screen VHS at 29.97 frames per second (which is lossless), edit, add effects, dub sound etc... and re-code to near VHS quality (the final file being a minuscule 6MB/min) for the total sum of...... 32 pounds!

Instead of editing deck to deck on VHS, I can do as much digital editing, effects, transitions, sound dub etc... as other people who have spent over 100 times that amount - most of whom will bounce down to VHS for public distribution/viewing anyway.  Don't get me wrong - one day I'll go down that route, and I'll be able to apply all the post production skills I am learning now.

But - er - is it worth it?

I had the DV versus VHS Desk Top Video debate with someone a few nights ago, so to prove a point I recorded a 30 second advert from TV (Digital TV, recorded on a 6 head VHS machine on a brand new cassette). Then I captured the video of the advert in full screen lossless codec (Huffyuv) at some 380+MB  and recorded that back to the video after the TV advert.  I then encoded the file with DivX  MPEG-4 (with all the filtering settings) and put that back onto VHS.  Finally I played the three versions back to back...and they had to agree that the final version (at 2.6MB) looked BETTER than the one recorded straight from TV !

OK - How do you do it?

Well a lot of people ask me that so in the end I converted my tattered scruffy penned notes into an HTML file and uploaded to my website.

I am no technical geek but after lots of playing around, web searching and lots of advice taking I stumbled across the method outlined in my web page - which works for me and fortunately the last computer I knocked together has a dual head function so I can output back to VHS.

The guide can also be used by DV users to archive their films onto CD-R without the limitations of creating VCD's or SVCD's.


Page updated on 21 March 2008

Authors' views are not necessarily those of The Institute of Amateur Cinematographers

Free JavaScripts provided
by The JavaScript Source